I asked this on reddit a couple of months ago and wanted a second opinion because the situation changed, Timmy was heavily damaged by the others in the colony, His wings are torn, his left side is flat and one of his antennae is partially gone, I removed him from the colony and placed him inside another enclosure that had two other males, literally a millisecond of putting him in one of the males went berserk so I put them back in the colony and left Timmy in the enclosure by himself, fast forward to now and TimTim is back with the colony and everything is much more better than when club penguin shut down, He doesn't get picked on, the females don't treat him like trash, He even attempted courting behavior(though it failed). I was wondering why he was treated like this? They all had enough space and if it was based on females other males would have looked the same and I doubt the two males would immediately go after him despite having no females. My Theory is that he was sick or something and they just sensed it and made attempts to get him to go away. Note: old pictures but still relevant TLDR: Timmy got beat up by the colony a couple of months ago but there really wasn't any -logical- reason and it was only him, everything is fine now.